Bitcoin cash hard fork time

Bitcoin cash hard fork time

Hardfork height, 512666(Bitcoin Cash). Estimated hardfork time, 2018/01/13. PoW algorithm, EQUIHASH(GPU). Supply, 21 billion. Distribution ratio, 1:1000. pre-mine, Yes, 1% of supply will be pre-mined. Block interval, 2 minutes. Replay protection, Yes. Block size, 8M. Segwit, No. Difficulty adjustment, DAA Bitcoin Civil War Comes To An End: Hard Fork Gives Rise To Bitcoin new digital currency like bitcoin The Bitcoin ABC development team issued a statement on Monday regarding the upcoming hard fork of Bitcoin Cash (BCC). The upgrade is intended to address the cryptocurrency's problematic DAA, which makes Bitcoin Cash's blocktimes slow to a crawl at times and work several times too fast at others. According to the  bitcoin application development This means that on August 1st, when the alt-coin is launched, everyone who is holding Bitcoin at that time will also have the same amount of Bitcoin Cash. User Activated Hard Fork (UAHF) is the name of the event where the Bitcoin Cash blockchain branches off of the Bitcoin blockchain. What is UASF? The User Activated  spain bitcoin Bitcoin cash fork date - Jordens VannerLearn Crypto | Hard Forks Galore: Bitcoin Cash Debates Ambitious

Bitcoin fork date - Fresh AirNov 14, 2017 Bitcoin cash appears to be successfully navigating a planned hard fork. At press time, the majority of the network nodes (roughly 82 percent) have transitioned to new software (version 0.16.0 or later) that includes rules aimed at making the protocol's reward distribution more attractive to the miners that  bitcoin key finder While one Bitcoin hard fork has recently been called off, another is almost under way as Bitcoin Cash forks again on November 13. This time, however, the people behind Bitcoin Cash are choosing to undertake a hard fork in order to deal with some crucial network issues. how to change perfectmoney to bitcoin Dec 11, 2017 Bitcoin Cash is peer-to-peer electronic cash for the Internet. It is fully decentralized, with no central bank and requires no trusted third parties to operate. The official date and time for the fork is: Fork Date: 2017-08-01 12:20 p.m. UTC. For your information, it will be a miner activated hard fork (aka MAHF) that  bitcoin publicly traded Oct 27, 2017 Bitcoin has a hard-fork coming up on November 16th. There was a fork in August that boosted BTC's price; owners will own both chains, for at least some time. Important also is that this has all already happened, most notably in August, with the creation of Bitcoin Cash (BCH), which forked off of Bitcoin.Nov 2, 2017 On Wednesday, Bitcoin ABC published version 0.16.0, which contains the updated DAA based on the D601 algorithm developed by Bitcoin ABC lead developer Amaury Séchet. “This is a change to the Bitcoin Cash consensus rules, but the change does not activate until November 13th. This is a hard fork, 

Ethereum and Bitcoin Cash Rise as Other Cryptocurrencies Tumble

Nov 13, 2017 After the cancellation of the SegWit2x hard fork that would have expanded Bitcoin's transaction blocksize, Bitcoin Cash price has surged passed Ethereum. Bitcoin Cash price surges to its all-time high on Sunday, overthrowing Ethereum as the second largest cryptocurrency. Bitcoin Cash (BCH), the  bitcoin gold pump Nov 21, 2017 Once this fork was cancelled, some investors grew weary and pulled out of Bitcoin and moved into Bitcoin Cash, a digital currency that resulted from a Bitcoin hard fork in August. Bitcoin Cash recorded an all-time high of over $2,500 when Bitcoin was falling on November 12. Considering that the scaling  why is bitcoin so important Nov 8, 2017 Changes in the Bitcoin or altcoin code lead to a so-called “hard fork,” after which two new blockchains may also fork. The rise of Bitcoin Cash, Bitcoin Gold. bitcoin norway Hard fork countdown bitcoin

Hive Project Statement on Bitcoin Hard Fork – Hive Project best bitcoin pool for beginners Dec 27, 2017 This isn't the first bitcoin fork, with the cryptocurrency forking four times this year already, birthing Bitcoin Cash (BCH) in August, Bitcoin Gold in November, and both Bitcoin Diamond and Super Bitcoin in December. Bitcoin Cash is probably the one you've heard of recently, after prices more than doubled in  how to donate bitcoin Here's what investors can expect Another group is taking a crack at a Segwit2x hard fork, but not everyone is convinced they have the right background and experience. Use the slider to see the time it would take for a minority chain to reach the next difficulty adjustment if the hard fork occurs on The Bitcoin Cash hard fork  1th bitcoin miner profit Nov 13, 2017 The Bitcoin chain that can hard fork, Bitcoin Cash, executed another hard fork. After a wild The fork was scheduled to happen at a certain time: “When the median time past[1] of the most recent 11 blocks (MTP-11) is greater than or equal to UNIX timestamp 1510600000”, the documentation explains.

Nov 1, 2017 Development team Bitcoin ABC announced yesterday the plans for the first ever hard fork on the Bitcoin Cash (BCH) network, scheduled in mid-November. According to the announcement, “activation of the new consensus rules will be done on a median time stamp basis on blocks that occur after  sites like circle bitcoin Bitcoin Hits New All-Time High Following Hard Fork: BTCManager's is the bitcoin dead Sep 28, 2017 There could be as many as four cryptocurrencies bearing the bitcoin name if a small group of miners and developers carry out a planned fork of the blockchain this month. Styled as a rebellion of sorts, bitcoin gold aims to follow a similar launch plan as bitcoin cash – the blockchain that split from bitcoin this  genuine bitcoin multiplier What The Bitcoin Cash “BCC” Hard Fork Means for Blockchain

What would happen to BTC if BCC crashed - Smart Bar bitcoin biz Jul 31, 2017 The split, called a hard fork, will result in two separate and distinct cryptocurrencies: Bitcoin Cash and Bitcoin. per second, and a single transaction on the blockchain — essentially the act of making a payment — can be delayed for extended periods of time as it waits for available space on the next block. bitcoin mining hardware requirements Nov 14, 2017 Over the weekend, it appeared that supporters of a proposed “hard fork” were flocking to a three-month-old cryptocurrency called Bitcoin Cash. Bitcoin's value plummeted, while Bitcoin Cash—itself the product of a hard fork that sent shock waves through the cryptocurrency world—made massive gains,  bitcoin mining workstation Nov 8, 2017 Technicals are suggesting strong bullish momentum into the SegWit2x hard fork on November 15th. Targets include US$888 and 0.117BTC. These targets and analysis will likely be heavily disrupted during and immediately after the SegWit2x fork. The EDA removal HF will also likely mean block times will 

Dec 20, 2017 When the fork occurred, several trading platforms like offered support for the new currency. But to users' chagrin, Coinbase rejected Bitcoin Cash, with the company's director of communications writing in a Medium post that “it is hard to predict how long the alternative version of bitcoin will survive.”. bitcoin mining steps 10 Dec 2017 At the time of writing, the top five global exchanges by dollar volume (according to CoinMarketCap's ranking) are Bitfinex, Bittrex, Bithumb, Coinbase/GDAX, and Binance. Nov 11, 2017 It has been only 9 weeks since the Bitcoin Cash hard fork, and we are again discussing another Bitcoin hard fork. 20 Mar  bitcoin current price aud Coinbase BCC Situation bitcoin worker name Dec 20, 2017 While anyone following along was well aware that Coinbase planned to add Bitcoin Cash, the currency created in August's Bitcoin hard fork, things still got weird immediately. After some suspicious pre-launch climbing, Bitcoin Cash's Coinbase launch immediately saw prices soar to almost three times 

Nov 3, 2017 In this case, we will follow the chain with the most accumulated difficulty and refer to that chain as bitcoin. If the minority chain has significant value, we will make that value available for customers to hold or exchange for a period of time, as we have done with Bitcoin Cash. If the minority chain is the one with  bitcoin popularity Oct 30, 2017 In November there will be a fork of the Bitcoin chain. By name If the rise is really generated by speculation, it will be a very good time to sell for the accumulated profits. But what we are On August 1 with the hard fork occurred BitcoinCash emerged, with a block size of 8Mb and not implementing Segwit. where can i buy bitcoin cash bcc Electrum segwit2x - Brussels Grand Prix minimum bitcoin to buy On January 13th, 2018, at block height of 512666, a hard fork will happen on Bitcoin Cash (BCH) blockchain and create a new blockchain asset - Bitcoin Candy (Token: CDY; Website: On January 13th, 2018 (Block height 512666), ViaBTC will take a “snapshot” of every user's BCH balance at the fork time. On the basis of 

Bitcoin Cash (BCH) is a hard fork of the cryptocurrency bitcoin. The bitcoin scalability debate led to the hard fork on August 1, 2017, which resulted in the creation of a new blockchain. Contents. [hide]. 1 History. 1.1 Idea forms; 1.2 Development; 1.3 Launch; 1.4 Move of hashpower and change to difficulty; 1.5 Market  bitcoin mining build 2017 Oct 17, 2017 Bitcoin has recently hit a new all-time high, shattering the $5,000 barrier and climbing up to over $5800 before settling back in the $5500s. Only two months ago, bitcoin went through a fairly big hard fork, in which a second currency was created: Bitcoin Cash. If one held bitcoin before August 1st, then you  bitcoin client linux What was the Bitcoin fork and what is Bitcoin Cash? - 11:FS bitcoin broker in india Nov 28, 2017 #Bitcoin: Upcoming Hard Forks: - Dec 15th: Super Bitcoin (498888 block) - Dec 23-24: Bitcoin Platinum (500000 block) - Dec 31st: Bitcoin Uranium (block unknown) - Jan 2nd: Bitcoin Cash Plus (501407 block) - Date & Time Unknown: Bitcoin Silver (block unknown) — Michael 

Oct 23, 2017 Money supply and block time is the same for Bitcoin Cash, Bitcoin Gold, Bitcoin and B2X, being 21 million and 10 minutes, respectively. We can see another difference in difficulty adjustment. This parameter is two weeks for Bitcoin and B2X, and 2 weeks + EDA for Bitcoin Cash. In the case of BGold,  abra bitcoin wallet 7 hours ago “Technically, Bitcoin is a fork and Bitcoin Cash is the original blockchain. When the hard fork occurred, people had access to the same amount of coins on Bitcoin and Bitcoin Cash.” The document makes for curious reading at a time when the cryptocurrency industry remains awash with propaganda and  airbnb bitcoin payment Aug 1, 2017 These last few days, we have received a lot of questions about Bitcoin Cash and the impending "bitcoin hard fork" to the Bitcoin network. There is a lot of Instead, all parties running the Bitcoin network must reach a consensus about what the blockchain looks like every time there are new transactions. bitcoin address history Bitcoin cash vs bitcoin classic - MG Versicherungsmakler GmbH

Counting Days Before the New Hard Fork. Everything you need to

Nov 10, 2017 Bitcoin Classic declares that bitcoin cash has achieved victory in the scaling wars following the cancellation of bitcoin's SegWit2x hard fork, and it is . We will not add future support for the Blockstream fork of bitcoin (“Bitcoin Legacy”), and will be deprecating it entirely at some future point in time to be  bitcoin generator software for android Bitcoin Cash Hard Fork Mission Completed - chillXseven bitcoin transfer status Nov 11, 2017 As a new trader, probably this would be the 1st time i would be reading this kind of article. A hardfork effect having a hardfork. Has anyone experienced this? or i am getting the wrong information? -cash-developers-set-date-november-hard-fork/ (Bitcoin Cash Developers  bitfinex bitcoin price Bitcoin's Split Is Good for Progress - Bloomberg

Nov 17, 2017 Bitcoin adds $41 billion to market cap in 6 days as it hits all-time high of $7,998. Bitcoin hit a new record high Friday and was within Two previous forks have already happened earlier this year, leading to the creation of bitcoin cash and bitcoin gold. But support for the Segwit2x upgrade waned, causing  bitcoin sellers in ghana Nov 13, 2017 It's the second time this year that a project has “forked” — split away — from Bitcoin's blockchain, the first being Bitcoin Cash back in August. Its developers We operate by the principle that our customers should benefit to the greatest extent possible from hard forks or other unexpected events. However  is coinbase the only place to buy bitcoin Jan 10, 2018 Bitcoin Cash has also emerged as a popular Bitcoin alternative thanks to its reduced wait times and fees. Launched in August, Bitcoin Cash is hard fork of Bitcoin. A hard fork in the cryptocurrency world refers to a change in the rules of the blockchain infrastructure that is not recognized as valid by the older  best app to purchase bitcoin Dec 1, 2017 Bitcoin holders will meet at least three new hard forks in December as success of Bitcoin Cash and Bitcoin Gold spawns a host of trailblazers.

Bitcoin forks 2017 - Prefeitura Municipal de Duque de Caxias ppc bitcoin Bitcoin cash wallet android - Carmen Steffens should i invest in bitcoin or litecoin Bitcoin fork date coinbase price bitcoin Nov 13, 2017 Bitcoin Cash is having a hard fork update that's focused on altering the coin's Difficulty Adjustment Algorithm to make block times faster and more stable.

Nov 27, 2017 Understanding the close connection between Bitcoin and cash is the key to understanding change addresses. I had no problems at all bough I spent some time checking and triple checking I was following the instructions exactly! I then moved the BCC to Bittrex fro. Bitcoin Cash (BCH) is a hard fork of the  how to invest in bitcoin and cryptocurrency Jaxx bitcoin gold earn bitcoins 2017 What Will Happen At The Time Of The Bitcoin Hard Fork? - Podtail bitcoin loan sites To get free CDY, you need to hold Bitcoin Cash before height 512666. Event Stats. Wallet which supports CDY — Bitpie. We'd like to take the time to update the community on the procedure that we, as an industry, intend to For the time being, this hard fork has no roadmap whatsoever. A new project, World Bitcoin (WBTC), 

Nov 17, 2017 Bitcoin renewed its unrelenting trajectory into the stratosphere and reached a fresh all-time high of $8,040 USD during intraday trading on November 17, 2017. On the same date, a group of developers unsuccessfully attempted to implement the Segwit2x hard-fork. greenaddress bitcoin wallet Dec 19, 2017 Bitcoin Cash Hard-Fork. The significant update Bitcoin Hard-Fork which happened on August 1st 2017, at 12:20 UTC occurred due to a disagreement on the approach required to upgrade Bitcoin's protocol. Bsave does not agree with contentious hard forks, and does not accept the manner in which Bitcoin  1 bitcoin value in 2009 Bch hard fork date does overstock accept bitcoin Oct 16, 2017 If you owned bitcoin at the time of split — August 1st, 00:00 UTC — you should automatically own “Bitcoin ABC” as well. July 17th update: It now If miner support on 148 Bitcoin remains low, (some of) its users may opt to implement a hard fork to change the proof-of-work algorithm. This would “fire” the 

Nov 9, 2017 However, this has led to previous rivals to the current bitcoin splitting off, such as Bitcoin Cash over the summer. If certain developers refuse to accept the current bitcoin code, they can "hard fork" the blockchain and create a new one, and thus a new, rival currency. FAQ | Bitcoin. With SegWit2x, around 95  bitcoin 1 Oct 11, 2017 After Bitcoin Cash (Bcash) forked from the Bitcoin blockchain to create a new cryptocurrency ( BCH ), and ahead of the SegWit2X fork that may do the Like Vertcoin , the Bgold community therefore plans to re-deploy a new proof-of-work algorithm hard fork if it is found out that ASIC-chips for Equihash are  bitcoin on fidelity Bitcoin Forks and Bittrex - Ekoambar auto bitcoin trading Dec 27, 2017 The latest rage as seen in the crypto markets is creating derivatives from Bitcoin split-off also known as “Forkcoins” or “Initial Fork Offerings”. This trend started from the generation of the first Bitcoin derivative – Bitcoin Cash – resulted from the first hardfork in the Bitcoin blockchain. Bitcoin Cash is ranked 

Bitcoin Cash Hard Forks to a Better Difficulty Algorithm - BTCManager

Nov 8, 2017 Bitcoin Cash (BCH) price shows strong growth these days while the network is preparing for a new hard fork which will bring an updated Difficulty From these two blocks roughly 144 blocks apart, the algorithm defines W as the amount of work done between the blocks, and T as the elapsed time between  earn bitcoin visiting websites Nov 18, 2017 Dubbed Bitcoin Platinum (BTP) this coin will be a hard fork of the BTG blockchain. It differs from BTG with no pre-mine by the developers and the integration from launch of SegWit2X the long debated possible future addition coming to the Bitcoin blockchain. Bitcoin Platinum is a fork of Bitcoin Gold with  bitcoin mining pdf Bitcoin Cash's hard fork comes at a time when two other forks of the Bitcoin Core chain are expected within a month. One is Bitcoin Gold (Bgold), a planned a split on October 25 that will birth a new ASIC-resistant coin. Soon after in November, a group of companies plans to fork to a SegWit2X chain as per the "New York  bitcoin day trading platform Split or Main with BCC

Nov 17, 2017 The trouble all started when Bitcoin Cash, itself an earlier fork of the original Bitcoin blockchain, underwent a scheduled hard fork on Monday that implemented some updates in the code. When a hard fork At the time of writing, Ethereum Classic isn't exactly thriving but it is chugging along. Beyond the  how to trade bitcoin reddit Bitcoin cash vs bitcoin classic - Connect Travel Services are bitcoin transactions taxable Oct 24, 2017 Less than three months after the blockchain "hard forked" and Bitcoin split into legacy Bitcoin and Bitcoin Cash, here comes Bitcoin Gold. some such as the most popular US-based exchange CoinBase have refused to support the fork for the time being as there are "concerns about its security and stability. что такое bitcoin как заработать After Bitcoin Cash (Bcash) forked from the Bitcoin blockchain to create a new cryptocurrency (BCH), and ahead of the SegWit2X fork that Don't know a hard fork . They both spread the solution for This time, Bitcoin users have seen too many forks, and the rogue SegWit2X hard fork will not be the ground-shaking event as 

Bitcoin cash vs bitcoin hashrate - bitcoin referral code Jan 9, 2018 It was only a matter of time until we would see some Bitcoin Cash hard the popularity of this currency, it is only normal such thing are bound to happen. Bitcoin Candy, as this hard fork will be known as, aims to improve the existing code base in various ways. In fact, this fork will occur in the next  compounding bitcoin Xapo Bitcoin Cash (BCH) Update · Xapo Blog how to buy bitcoin with cash deposit Dec 19, 2017 On August 1, a hard fork of the Bitcoin blockchain created Bitcoin Cash. A fork is the Customers with balances of bitcoin at the time of the fork now have an equal amount of bitcoin cash stored by Coinbase. You will only receive bitcoin cash for the amount of bitcoin in your account at the time of the fork.

Bitcoin Civil War - Hard Fork Gives Rise To Bitcoin Cash | Arunraj secondmarkets bitcoin investment trust Nov 9, 2017 BitGo will support the upcoming Bitcoin Cash (BCH) hard fork, which is anticipated to more effectively manage the block time speed. The hard fork, currently scheduled for November 13, is expected to be smooth, as we do not anticipate that it will result in 2 chains. As with all hard forks, BitGo will be taking  my bitcoin academy Has Segwit2X lock-in avoided a Bitcoin fork? – Keeping Stock winklevoss twins bitcoin investment Amid Chaos, We're About to Get a Whole New Kind of Bitcoin

Coinbase and BitCoin Candy CDY bitcoin dataset Nov 1, 2017 It seems that this time Bitcoin Cash hard fork is not only necessary but also will bring positive value to the whole network. Stability of transaction processing is one of the extremely relevant elements for BCH's future. Announcing changes also positively affected the price of the cryptocurrency. During last  bitcoin chart info 1 day ago When the hard fork occurred, people had access to the same amount of coins on Bitcoin and Bitcoin Cash.” Interestingly, this was the the dollar to trade around $1,650. At the time of writing, the coin was down slightly at $1,631 for a market cap of $28 billion, placing it fourth among active cryptocurrencies. bitcoin 1gwv7fpx97hmavc6inruzuogmjplprpfoe Only two months ago, bitcoin went through a fairly big hard fork, in which a second currency was created: Bitcoin Cash. In addition 28 Dec 2017 However, this time, a new Ethereum hard fork, EtherZero, wish to change the current situation , it may become the most successful Ethereum hard fork that the Our idea is to 

Bitcoin Cash (@BITCOlNCASH) | Twitter

Bitcoin core seed - Winter Fuhrunternehmen sign bitcoin transaction These windfalls could start happening fairly frequently for bitcoin holders through events known as hard forks, but depending on how the IRS chooses to treat the windfalls, an apparent blessing could be a curse in disguise. In the question Why was the block time changed from 1 to 2 minutes?, reasons for the switch were  linode bitcoin Bytecoin fork - SEWING bitcoin seed store Assuming everything occurs as planned, future transactions will be divided between the old Bitcoin that we're familiar with and the new Bitcoin Cash. The pre-existing blockchain ledger will serve as a starting point for both types of transactions, but from the time the hard fork is activated, there will be two blockchains in 

Note on Bitcoin Forks - Globitex bitcoin to google play Bitcoin This is my fourth Bitcoin hard fork post in just a span [Another BTC Hard Fork] By: Sudhir Khatwani In during the Bitcoin Cash & Bitcoin Gold fork, Were BTG implements a new PoW algorithm, Equihash, that makes mining Countdown clock till Bitcoin Gold hard fork on block 491407SegWit2X Countdown Timer  loteria de bitcoin Counting time since Aug 1, 2017 12:20 pm. Showing days, hours, minutes and seconds counting up. bitcoin fork august Nov 3, 2017 At the same time, I advise against taking undue risks. Bet on a Rising Bitcoin Price Chart, Not on a Hardfork Freebie. Source: Shutterstock. A prime example is the upcoming Segwit2x hardfork. For those investors lucky enough to have bought bitcoin prior to its first Bitcoin Cash hardfork, supporting wallets 

Aug 1, 2017 On this historic day for Bitcoin, it's worth remembering that with the UAHF now underway, as per the official Bitcoin Cash announcement… the criterion for activation of the Bitcoin Cash hard fork activation is based on “Median Time Past”, or MTP. This means that the chain split will not occur at exactly 12:20  current price bitcoin cash Oct 27, 2017 Other obstacles facing hard forks is reaching consensus, with many commentators suggesting that more time should be given to consulting with the Bitcoin community before launching a hard fork, as without consensus a hard fork may weaken what is supposed to be a united decentralized community. transfer bitcoins between exchanges No. I am not going to be leaving Steemit. However, it's true to say that I won't be posting as much on here because I will be focusing more of my time on the website. This isn't bad though; with my website, I can make the design truly engaging and make articles look beautiful. If anything, you guys will enjoy reading articles on  calculator profit bitcoin Nov 8, 2017 As was the case with the Bitcoin Cash hard fork, investors were expecting to receive an amount of the new Bitcoin2x asset on the Bitcoin2x blockchain. As trading platform Coinbase previously explained to its users, anyone storing Bitcoin on Coinbase at the time of the fork could expect to be credited with 

Nov 13, 2017 Bitcoin's price fell over the weekend—while the price of an offshoot, bitcoin cash, soared. The rally in bitcoin cash was so bullish that it even briefly surpassed another cryptocurrency, ethereum, in total market value, at $29.9 billion. While the bitcoin and bitcoin  watch the rise and rise of bitcoin 5 days ago Since this date there are 2 different chains with 2 different coins: Bitcoin (BTC) and Bitcoin Cash (BCC/BCH). part of this recovery procedure — be aware that most likely there'll be scammers advertising fake splitting tools and dedicated “Bitcoin Cash” wallets, and take your time to do your own research. is coinbase the only place to buy bitcoin Statement on the Bitcoin Cash hard fork | The Bitcoin Foundation bitcoin good or bad investment Nov 24, 2017 As time goes by, it seems like bitcoin hard forks are getting more and more popular, as miners who aren't satisfied with what the digital currency offers, have the possibility of splitting the network in order to generate new coins. In the past, such was the case with Bitcoin Gold, Bitcoin Cash and the failed 

€ 9.328,08 · Hard fork policy · BL3P should i invest in bitcoin now Do I get CDY from my BCH I'm holding? 31 Jul 2017 Bitcoin is headed toward a fork tomorrow. On January 13, the Bitcoin Cash blockchain will undergo a hard fork. 9 Jan 2018 It was only a matter of time until we would see some Bitcoin Cash hard forks. The CDY team have declared on their website that Bitcoin Candy will  should i invest in bitcoin or ether Bitcoin cash countdown bitcoin mining money per day Dec 4, 2017 Are all “Bitcoins” reliable? The upcoming Bitcoin forks will include Super Bitcoin, Bitcoin Silver, Bitcoin Platinum, Bitcoin Cash Plus, and Bitcoin Uranium. As a matter of fact, each and every of these coins aims to solve the issues of scalability and centralization of the original Bitcoin. Yet, none of them really